pkgs.formats.javaProperties: Add implementation note to type

This commit is contained in:
Robert Hensing 2022-04-04 13:11:00 +02:00
parent 83bf24b066
commit ef6d9dfd71

View file

@ -1,6 +1,30 @@
{ lib, pkgs }:
{
javaProperties = { comment ? "Generated with Nix" }: {
# Design note:
# A nested representation of inevitably leads to bad UX:
# 1. keys like "a.b" must be disallowed, or
# the addition of options in a freeformType module
# become breaking changes
# 2. adding a value for "a" after "a"."b" was already
# defined leads to a somewhat hard to understand
# Nix error, because that's not something you can
# do with attrset syntax. Workaround: "a"."", but
# that's too little too late. Another workaround:
# mkMerge [ { a = ...; } { a.b = ...; } ].
#
# Choosing a non-nested representation does mean that
# we sacrifice the ability to override at the (conceptual)
# hierarchical levels, _if_ an application exhibits those.
#
# Some apps just use periods instead of spaces in an odd
# mix of attempted categorization and natural language,
# with no meaningful hierarchy.
#
# We _can_ choose to support hierarchical config files
# via nested attrsets, but the module author should
# make sure that problem (2) does not occur.
type = lib.types.attrsOf lib.types.str;
generate = name: value: